Dear Dr. Ellen: I was recently married after a two-year courtship.
Because this is a second marriage for Bob and me, we had a private,
small ceremony and an open house where we invited family only so they
could get to know one another. My son John, 23, is an only child, and
has few relatives. He was very excited that he would become part of my
husband's large family, who has lots of "cousins." A couple weeks prior
to the wedding, my son asked me to speak to my husband's brothers and
sisters and ask them to pass along that he was inviting his new cousins
to his home after the open house, which was held in the early afternoon.
He took a day off work to get ready. At the open house, he found out
that none of my husband's brothers and sisters had mentioned this to
their children, so he personally walked around to each new cousin to
invite them to his home. I walked around with him to introduce him. Each
cousin said they would be there. They were excited about getting
together. None of them showed up. To make it worse, I overheard the
cousins planning to go to a cousin's home, and John was not invited. I
think that John was hurt by this situation. Although he has not
personally been invited to the Thanksgiving dinner that is being planned
by Bob's family, I felt that I could invite him. He declined. When I
talked to my husband, I mentioned that I thought John was somewhat hurt
about the above incident. His reply was that they didn't mean anything
by it, John should get over it, and he didn't want to discuss it again.
I do not plan to be in the middle or even necessarily pursue anything,
but now I am looking for peace of mind myself. I would appreciate any
comments you may have. - Janet
Dear Janet: It's hard to believe that in a two year courtship, your son
would not have already met your husband's family at Christmas or
Thanksgiving. As for this particular disappointment, since it was not a
formal invitation, and John didn't call his cousins directly, I feel
that your husband's brothers and sisters simply thought of it as a nice,
casual, unplanned "afterthought" and it was not a big deal. I'm sure, if
they did mention it to their own children, it was a "by the way, John
wants to have the cousins over his home after the wedding." Young
adults, in their early 20's are all living their own lives and their
parents have very little influence over what they do or don't do. His
cousins probably felt uncomfortable going to John's house without really
knowing him. For them, the less embarrassing way out, was to smile
politely and have no real intention of going because they had already
made other plans, not realizing how hurt he would be. How many times
have you heard another adult say, "I'll call you" and they don't, or "We
should get together soon," and you never hear from them? I think that it
will take time for his cousins to think of him as "family" and that
happens over time and many family gatherings. John sounds like a
wonderful, mature, young man who has every reason to be hurt. He went
out of his way to personally invite every one of them and they never
showed up, after agreeing to come. The thing that concerns me the most
is your husband's reaction. You would think that he would be concerned
about his family's lack of sensitivity to his new step-son. Instead, his
comment that "John should get over it, and he didn't want to discuss it
again," sounds very cold and insensitive to me. I would think that he
would want to talk to John himself, just to praise him for what he tried
to do, and let him know how he understands his disappointment. You may
want to talk to your son and tell him to try and make one more attempt
by coming to Thanksgiving. Explain to him that they just don't really
know him and that would be a great chance for them to see what a
terrific young man he is. Most importantly, it would mean so much to you
to have him there. He may think that now that you have a new family, you
don't need him and that is the last thing you want him to think.
Regardless of whether he agrees or not, you should validate his feelings
and tell him how proud you are of him. - Dr. Ellen