Dear Dr. Ellen: My husband and I work at the same company but on
different shifts. Recently, my husband was told by someone he works with
that I have cheated on him. I don't know you and you don't know me so I
have no reason to lie. I've never in all of the years we have been
married, cheated on my husband. The person who did this told my husband
that she saw me coming out of someone's house on a street that I am not
even familiar with. Then he said that when he mentioned this to a few
more people, they all said, and I quote, "They suspected something of
the sort." I guess my question is, how does a person prove they're
innocent about something they've never done. I'm innocent but if I were
in my husband's shoes, I think I would believe it too, if two or more
people are saying it. He refuses to let me confront these individuals to
get to the truth. I'm not worried about what they're saying because God
knows and I know it's not true but what does upset me is my husband
believes it. I've been with this man for years and he can't even give me
the benefit of the doubt? He just continues to believe some people who
are spreading a bunch of lies. I think, no, I know, I deserve better. I
can't be with a man that can't trust me or vice versa. I feel marriage
is about trust and sometimes your are put to the test. My husband is
failing miserably. Some people see you happy, loving one other and they
can't handle it. They have to drive a wedge between you. How can I prove
that I'm innocent when he won't tell me who's saying such awful things?
- Carrie
Dear Carrie: You are 100% correct in that marriage is about trust. If
you can't trust your spouse, who in the world can you trust? There is
something very wrong with your marriage if, you too, would trust a group
of people instead of your husband. If someone accused me or my husband
of being unfaithful or committing a terrible crime, we would trust each
other completely and not care if the entire world said we were guilty.
The fact that this is happening to you means you really have to ask
yourself a very hard question, "Why would I stay with a man who takes
another person's word over mine?" You are right, I don't know you or
your husband, but there is absolutely no reason for you to write to me
if you were guilty. How dare your husband treat you with such disrespect
and not defend your honor!! One of the things I teach men is that every
woman needs a man who will defend her against anyone who dishonors her
in any way. And then to add insult to injury, he has the nerve to keep
you from knowing who said these things. There is either something very
wrong with your husband's allegiance or he's lying to you and made this
up himself.
Many times when someone accuses another person of being unfaithful or
untrustworthy, or lying, it is a sign that they themselves are that way.
If he accuses you of lying, it's because he lies. If he accuses you of
looking at another man, it's because he looks at other women. If he is
accusing you of being unfaithful, it's because he is unfaithful. We
always see others through our own actions. He is projecting his own
faults and shortcomings onto you. We teach others how we want to be
treated and you need to raise the bar.
You asked me how you can prove that you are innocent. The answer is that
you can't. All you have is your word. If that is not good enough for
your husband, you certainly cannot stay in a marriage where you are
being punished for something you never did." So, here is what you say to
your husband. "I have repeatedly told you that I am not having an
affair. I will not continue repeating this over and over. You can take
the next 24 hours and decide whether you believe me or not. If you
choose to believe other people and their word means more to you than
mine, then we will have to separate. I will not continue to be punished
for something I didn't do. I don't care if 1000 people tell you that I
have been unfaithful. After all these years, you should know me well
enough to defend my reputation. It should be you and I against the world
and not you and the world against me." If he continues the accusations,
you'll have to make arrangements to leave. Under no circumstances should
you allow him back in your life until he is willing to confront this
person in front of you. You deserve that! - Dr. Ellen